Walter Edward Workman & Bertha Etta Mullins, 1931-1937 (The Roughs of Buffalo Creek)

A Note About This Folder:

In general, I have an abundance of family photos from each phase of Granny and Grandpa’s life…except for their time at Buffalo Creek. Probably for multiple reasons, they just didn’t take any photographs. Perhaps it was because of economic distress caused by the Great Depression, or the extreme isolation of the farm, or maybe they did not have a camera or access to processing. The photos that are posted here were either taken in later years or acquired from available resources.

What we don’t have in terms of pictures, we make up for with vivid storytelling from Uncle Damon and Uncle Doyle. Fortunately, I was able to make some high quality audio recordings so we can enjoy the memories. In most cases, I have included transcriptions along with the audio track. It would be my enthusiastic recommendation that you always listen to the story first. The word-pictures are terrific, and the passion and intensity are conspicuous!

One additional comment about the title. There is some uncertainty about the year they moved to the farm…whether it was 1930 or 1931. Dale was born in 1930, according to sources, in Adair. However, Damon seems to think that they moved there after Dale was born. For now, I am leaving the date as 1931.

The timeline below provides a summary of Walter and Bertha’s experience on Buffalo Creek. It was a short period, but one that was sprinkled with life-changing events.

Buffalo Creek Farm


Moving from Maysel to Buffalo Creek farm

As mentioned in the previous section, the Great Depression caused their hardware business to fail. That’s when Walter and Bertha moved to the farm on Buffalo Creek. Damon said that the Albert Mullins family was from the Maysel area, northwest of Clay. It appears that the logging business led to the Mullins family acquiring a lot of land (including the farm on Buffalo Creek). Damon expands on this thought with the following narrative:

Mike: How'd they ever find that place? [Buffalo Creek]

Damon: Grandpa… way back in his times, it was in the Mullins family. The Mullins owned some property up in there and on up to the dairy farm, the Mullins used to own that. [The dairy farm was built and operated by ERC&L Company, in Cressmont. See the Resources section for more info.]

But this ole farm there that Daddy and Mom lived on was back in the Mullins family, back in the turn of century around 1900. Mom said she could remember standing there and watching when they started that railroad, when they come up the Buffalo surveying to build that railroad. That was in 1904, I believe. See, she'd have been six years old, I believe. And they [the Mullins] lived up there at that time. Grandpa just moved wherever he could get a few days’ work, just like everybody else did. You didn't have steady employment anywhere.

[To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below.]

[DEWv1: Albert gave Buffalo Creek farm to Walter & Bertha (10:46-11:32)]

And then when they did that... of course, my thoughts are that Grandpa [Albert] didn't want to put up with them, so he just moved them up on that old farm. Now whether Grandpa gave them the farm or whether...I don't see how they could have bought it. They were just too poor to have bought it. I just kinda figured he just gave it to them to get rid of them. See, we moved up there when Dale was just a baby, and he was born in 1930. So, we must have moved up there by the spring, early spring of '31, I'd say probably.

DEWv1 Albert gave Buffalo Creek farm to Walter & Bertha
Damon Workman

A visit to the Buffalo Creek farm

In September, 1970, my family (Denvil, Kate, Bus, Jaynet and Mike) traveled over to Clay to explore Walter and Bertha’s homestead on Buffalo Creek. As you can see on the map above, the farm was (and still is) very isolated. There is a road from Dundon to Avoca, the last portion of which traversed through huge GOB piles. These GOB (garbage of bituminous) piles are the material left over from coal mining, some of which is nonflammable. The piles shown in the photos below were cleaned up around the turn of the century. From Avoca onward (upstream) the only road is the creek bed itself. Fortunately, Dad’s pickup was up to the task. It also helped that the water level was low.

The train equipment in the photos was stored just east of Dundon. Engine #14 was in operation into the early 1960’s. It should be noted that the state of West Virginia purchased the bulk of the BC&G equipment for the Cass Scenic Railroad.

We were able to drive up to the farm (the last photo in the gallery below shows the open pasture where crops were raised). I don’t remember if the house was still standing at that time. We were later informed that it had been burned down by vandals unknown. I do not have any photos of the house…I am hoping that one surfaces along the way. Damon used to build wooden models of the house—those may be the only remaining remnants that show what it looked like.

Another visit to the Buffalo Creek farm

Forty-two years later, I made another trip to Buffalo Creek with Uncle Damon and Eddie. Clay is directly north of Fayetteville via SR16, but the road is anything but straight (or level). A little north of Bentree, there is an historical marker commemorating, Solomon Osborne and Seaberry Arms. These Cherokee Indians were my ancestors on Mom’s side…and also ancestors of Aunt Mae.

Eddie had enlisted the help of Jerry Nelson, who is the current owner of the Buffalo Creek farm property. I don’t know how much land he has now, but there was more than 100 acres when Walter & Bertha owned it. Jerry has a farm just off CR11, near Triplett. He uses the Buffalo Creek farm for hunting. Jerry guided us (over remote, 4-wheel drive only roads) to the property.

The photo gallery below chronicles the trip. Here a few comments about that day:

• The property is still remote and nearly inaccessible. You need a 4-wheel drive vehicle to get there.

• Jerry kept the fields cut down to attract deer. Deer is common in the area, as evidenced by the fact that we saw one as we were leaving the property. Trees on the rest of the property had grown unrestrained.

• The house that Walter and Bertha lived in was no longer standing. Apparently, vandals burned it to the ground. The foundation stones remained in piles on the site. I don’t know who originally built the house, but they demonstrated first-rate masonry skills. The stones had straight edges and flat surfaces, crafted only with hand tools.

• I noticed that the huge GOB pile at Avoca had been cleaned up. In general, the environmental impact of coal mining in the 1900’s has undergone significant remediation. I have read that trout are now stocked in the Buffalo Creek.

• In 2012, the BC&G railroad tracks were so overgrown that you could hardly see them. In recent years, locals have cleaned up (and repaired) the tracks and are making inroads with tourism attractions. (See the Resources Section/Clay County Info for details.)

The School at Adair

During their sojourn on Buffalo Creek, the kids would have attended elementary school at Adair (see map). All of the details that I have are contained in the following audio clip that I recorded with Uncle Damon. To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv1 Railroad along Buffalo Creek; community of Adair
Damon Workman

Phyllis catches up with Denvil

Denvil and Phyllis graduated from high school in the same year, although Denvil was 20 months older. Somewhere along the way, Phyllis moved ahead a grade. My guess is that this occurred early on. Since their elementary schools were small and short on teachers, combining grades would have been a way to maximize teaching time.

Five attend Adair School

Five of the kids attended the one-room Adair School: Denvil and Phyllis for 5 years; Freda for 6 years, Damon for 3 years; and Dale only one. [These are calculated numbers, based on their age.

Damon’s 2nd grade report card is the only record that I have found. It is interesting that Lenna Mullins (a great-aunt) was the 3rd grade teacher. The principal was Ezelle Ramsey (perhaps another cousin?).

Riding the train

Denvil and Phyllis would have ridden the train to high school for their freshman and sophomore years (1936 and 1937). It is about 4 miles to Clay (each way). They would either wade across the Buffalo Creek (barefoot, of course) or walk about 1-1/2 miles down to Avoca where there was a bridge. Dad told me that he would often walk the entire distance.


Life on Buffalo Creek

Life was hard on the Buffalo Creek farm. It was isolated; they had no close neighbors. There were no roads to the house. The BC&G Railroad was their only connection to civilization (and the nearest bridge across the Buffalo Creek to the railroad was a mile and a half away).

There was no electricity or natural gas for cooking or heating. A wood-burning fireplace provided heat, although they may have had a coal-burning furnace later. Coal was certainly abundant.

Their sojourn on the farm came in the middle of the Great Depression. Everyone was affected.

Raising and preserving food was nearly a fulltime job. Damon said that Walter was not a farmer. At the very least he was an inexperienced farmer. He supplemented his income by making coffins. I am not aware of any other jobs he may have had at that time.

The kids matured early in life; they took on adult responsibilities while still children.

We can look at the farm today and tend to romanticize it, forgetting how difficult it would have been to live there without modern conveniences.

The following audio recordings (and transcriptions) give a firsthand account of what life was like for the family. As you listen to Damon and Doyle tell the stories, imagine yourself in their shoes.

After reviewing these recordings multiple times, I have to say that I certainly admire the character, perseverance, and courage demonstrated by Walter and Bertha, Denvil and Damon. As you listen to the stories, I hope they inspire you as they did me.

Damon and Mae

Damon, Dale, Doyle

Buffalo Creek Recollections—circa 1932

Doyle was born at home on the Buffalo Creek farm (in 1932). So. he was only five when they moved to Bentree; consequently, he had very few actual memories of his time there. His recollections were based on information passed down from various family members. As with Damon, Doyle emphasized the remoteness of the home and the hardships of living off the land.

The USGS topo map clearly shows the location of the house relative to Buffalo Creek. The map shown here was published in 1967. I have seen an earlier version issued in 1904 that shows the same thing. This tells me the house was built before 1904. I do not know who the actual builder was.

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DCWv2 Buffalo Creek farm recollections
Doyle Workman

Hardships on the Buffalo Creek; food storage problems—circa 1932

Perhaps the biggest problem they faced was raising and preserving enough food to last from year to year. The only refrigeration came via natural means. The photo shows the remains of their food cellar. According to Damon, it did an adequate job of slowing decay…but it was never meant for long-term storage. It’s a miracle they didn’t die of malnutrition.

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv1 Hardships on the Buffalo Creek farm; food storage problems
Damon Workman

Denvil getting corn ground at Rhodes’ Grist Mill—circa 1932

Walter alludes to getting groceries at Rhodes Store (in Swandale). This was actually the ERC&L company store; Jay Rhodes was the manager. This photo was taken in the 1920’s.

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv2 Denvil getting corn ground at Rhodes's Grist Mill
Damon Workman

Harvesting corn, feeding livestock, raising crops; Walter not a farmer—circa 1932

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv2 Harvesting corn, feeding livestock, raising crops; Walter not a farmer
Damon Workman

Walter made coffins for the locals—circa 1933

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv3 Walter made coffins for the locals
Damon Workman

Uncle Washy Mullins’s funeral story—circa 1933

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv3 Uncle Washy Mullins’s funeral story
Damon Workman

Slaughtered hog stolen from house on Buffalo Creek, outside Damon’s bedroom—circa 1935

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv4 Slaughtered hog stolen from house on Buffalo Creek, outside Damon’s bedroom
Damon Workman

Feeding hog; Bertha inadvertently “riding” it—circa 1935

Bertha “riding the hog”, duplicate story—circa 1935

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv5 Feeding hog; Bertha inadvertently “riding” it
Damon Workman
DEWv14 Bertha “riding the hog”, duplicate story
Damon Workman

Caring for hogs in the wild; Damon without shoes, in snow; branding livestock—circa 1935

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv6 Caring for hogs in the wild; Damon without shoes, in snow; branding livestock
Damon Workman

Hogs eating chestnuts; prep for slaughter—circa 1935

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv6 Hogs eating chestnuts; prep for slaughter
Damon Workman

Eating meat in the summertime—circa 1935

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv6 Eating meat in the summertime
Damon Workman

Hunting small game; deer was scarce; deer re-population effort—circa 1935

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv6 Hunting small game; deer was scarce; deer re-population effort
Damon Workman

Making molasses using a horse; dog tackling the horse—circa 1936

Was the dog in this story the same one as in this 1940’s Bentree photo? “Old Billy Dog” was his name. Damon called the dog in this story (and the hog story) by the name “Bill”. It could have been the same dog, or maybe this one was the next generation of dogs named Bill.

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv14 Making molasses using a horse; dog tackling the horse
Damon Workman

Denvil & Damon move big hog from Buffalo Creek farm to Dundon—April 1, 1937

To hear Damon tell this story, click the audio button below. If you want to see the transcription, click on + sign in the “accordion” bar below it.

DEWv1 Denvil & Damon move big hog from Buffalo Creek farm to Dundon
Damon Workman